The basic rule
Without prejudice privilege is a rule of evidence. It prevents a party from showing a court the content of genuine settlement negotiations without the other side's consent. The rule exists so that parties can speak candidly when trying to settle — if every offer could be shown to a judge, parties would never make realistic offers for fear of appearing weak. The leading case is Rush & Tompkins Ltd v Greater London Council [1989] AC 1280, where the House of Lords confirmed the privilege extends beyond the immediate parties to protect the settlement process generally.
When the label alone is not enough
Marking a letter "without prejudice" does not automatically protect it. The privilege only attaches if the communication is a genuine attempt to settle a dispute that already exists or is reasonably in contemplation. A letter threatening legal action for the first time is not protected simply because it carries the label. Conversely, a communication can be protected even without the label if it is clearly part of settlement negotiations. Courts look at substance, not form. If you are unsure, use the label — but do not rely on it alone.
Without prejudice save as to costs (Part 36)
A Part 36 offer is a formal settlement offer under CPR Part 36. It is "without prejudice save as to costs" — meaning it cannot be shown to the judge on the merits, but after judgment the judge can see it to decide who should pay costs. If you beat your own Part 36 offer, the paying party faces enhanced costs consequences. Part 36 is therefore more powerful than an informal without-prejudice offer. For how to use it in practice, see the without prejudice negotiations guide.
Exceptions to the rule
The privilege is not absolute. Courts have allowed without-prejudice communications to be shown where: (1) the dispute is about whether a concluded agreement was reached (the communication is needed to prove or disprove the settlement itself); (2) the communication contains a clear statement of fact that amounts to an admission, unconnected with the settlement offer; (3) the privilege is used as a shield to cover up misrepresentation, fraud, or undue influence; or (4) the communication contains perjury or an attempt to mislead the court. These exceptions are narrow and courts apply them strictly.
Practical tips
Always label settlement correspondence "Without Prejudice" and date it clearly. Keep a separate file for WP correspondence — do not mix it with open correspondence. If you receive a without-prejudice letter, do not forward it to the court without taking advice. Remember that the other party's consent is needed to lift the privilege. If you want to make a formal offer with cost consequences, use Part 36 instead of a simple without-prejudice letter. For high-value disputes, ask a solicitor to draft the offer — a poorly worded Part 36 offer can fail to trigger the cost consequences you intended.