Short answer
"Without prejudice" is a legal protection that stops settlement offers and negotiation correspondence from being shown to a court as evidence of an admission. It only works if the communication is a genuine attempt to settle a dispute — marking a document "without prejudice" does not automatically protect it.
"Without prejudice save as to costs" is a related but different concept, used in formal settlement offers (Part 36 offers). These can be shown to the court after judgment but only on the question of costs.
1 The rule
The without prejudice rule is judge-made (common law), codified by the Evidence Act and confirmed by the House of Lords. It protects the parties' willingness to compromise from being used against them.
"The without prejudice rule is a rule governing the admissibility of evidence and is founded upon the public policy of encouraging litigants to settle their differences rather than litigate them to a finish."Read the official text
The protection is automatic when the conditions are met — it is not created solely by the words "without prejudice" on a document. A court will look at the substance of the communication.
2 What you can do now
- Decide whether you want the communication protected
Only use "without prejudice" for genuine settlement offers or conciliatory negotiations. Do not mark everything "without prejudice" — it devalues the protection and can lead to confusion.
- Mark the document clearly
Put "WITHOUT PREJUDICE" in the subject line and at the top of any letter or email. Keep the rest of the correspondence separate from "open" (non-protected) correspondence.
- Make a genuine offer
The communication must be a genuine attempt to resolve the dispute. A pure threat or demand without any concession or offer is unlikely to attract the protection even if marked "without prejudice".
- Consider Part 36 for formal settlement offers
If you are making a formal offer you want the court to know about (for costs purposes), use a Part 36 offer under the Civil Procedure Rules 1998. This is "without prejudice save as to costs" — after judgment, the court can consider whether the other side failed to beat your offer.
3 When this does not apply
- The without prejudice protection does not apply to allegations of fraud, undue influence, or illegality made in the without prejudice correspondence itself.
- If both parties agree, without prejudice communications can be shown to the court.
- Once a final settlement is reached, the settlement agreement itself is "open" (not protected) and can be enforced.
4 Common questions
Does marking something "without prejudice" guarantee it cannot be used in court?
No. The label creates a presumption of protection, but a court can override it. If the communication was not a genuine attempt to settle a dispute, the court can find the without prejudice rule does not apply. Conversely, a communication can attract the protection even without the label if it is clearly part of settlement negotiations. The substance matters more than the label. See the <a href="/glossary/without-prejudice" class="body-link">without prejudice glossary entry</a> for a detailed explanation.
What is the difference between "without prejudice" and "without prejudice save as to costs"?
"Without prejudice" (WP) means the communication cannot be shown to the court at all — it is completely protected. "Without prejudice save as to costs" (WPSATC) is used for formal Part 36 offers: the offer cannot be shown to the judge deciding the case, but after judgment the court can consider it when deciding who pays the legal costs. WPSATC is a tactical tool — if you make a reasonable offer and the other side refuses and then fails to beat it at trial, they may be ordered to pay costs.
Sources